In Amex on Shifting Sands I argued that Membership Rewards isn’t collapsing — its value is moving out of transfer partners and into credits. Look at Chase’s refreshed Sapphire Reserve next to it and the same thing is happening there. These are no longer two points cards with a few perks attached. They’re two coupon books with points attached.
The Fees
The Amex Platinum is now $895 a year. The Chase Sapphire Reserve is $795, plus $195 for each authorized user. Neither card earns that back on points alone for most people. Both issuers sell the fee the same way: add up the credits and the number on the page is bigger than the fee.
Side by Side
Here is every credit each issuer lists on its own card page, and — more importantly — how often you have to use it before it resets.
| Amex Platinum | Sapphire Reserve | |
|---|---|---|
| Hotels | $600 Lodging Credit — $300 each half-year on prepaid Fine Hotels + Resorts, The Hotel Collection or Airbnb Luxe | $500 for The Edit — up to $250 per prepaid booking, two-night minimum |
| Travel | $200 airline fee credit — one airline you pick, incidentals only | $300 travel credit — almost any travel purchase, per account year |
| Dining | $400 Resy — $100 each quarter | $300 dining — $150 each half-year at OpenTable Exclusive Tables restaurants |
| Rides & delivery | $200 Uber Cash — $15 a month, $35 in December; $120 Uber One | $120 Lyft — $10 a month; DashPass plus up to $35 a month in DoorDash promos |
| Streaming | $300 digital entertainment — $25 a month | Apple TV and Apple Music — activate by June 22, 2027 |
| Shopping & fitness | $300 lululemon — $75 each quarter; $155 Walmart+ — $12.95 a month; $200 Oura Ring | $300 StubHub — $150 each half-year; $120 Peloton — $10 a month |
| Airport | $219 CLEAR+ | Up to $120 application-fee credit, once every four years |
| Airbnb extra | Up to $250 Airbnb Experiences — only after you book a prepaid Airbnb Luxe stay | — |
Add up what each issuer lists and you get roughly $2,700 on the Platinum (before the Airbnb Experiences credit) and roughly $2,500 on the Reserve. That’s the sum of the credits each issuer lists — their own headline figures are higher ($3,500+ for Amex, $3,000+ for Chase) because they also count perks like lounge access. What you actually capture depends on how many of these you’d have paid for anyway — and how many you remember.
The Real Cost Is the Calendar
The dollar totals hide the part that matters: the rhythm. Count the deadlines.
That’s more than a dozen separate clocks across two cards — before you think about points at all. This is the trade both issuers have made: less value in what your points can do, more value in what the card subscribes you to. I wrote about Chase’s side in detail in my one-year Sapphire Reserve review.
Where They Differ
Chase’s credits are easier to use. The $300 travel credit covers almost any travel purchase, and it alone takes a big bite out of the fee. Amex’s $200 airline credit is locked to one airline’s incidental fees, and the old workarounds are gone.
Amex’s credits are more frequent. Monthly and quarterly slices reward people who already use Uber, Resy and lululemon. If you don’t, a lot of that $2,700 is money you’d have to go out of your way to spend.
The Edit costs more, but Chase may price-match. In my experience, The Edit has fewer hotels than Amex’s Fine Hotels + Resorts, and the rates are often higher than booking the same room elsewhere. What makes it workable for me is Chase Travel’s Price Match Guarantee, a beta that only some Sapphire Reserve cardholders see. Find the same room cheaper within 24 hours of booking and you can claim the difference from My Trips.
Both hotel credits now need two nights. Chase’s The Edit already requires two. Amex’s Hotel Collection and Airbnb Luxe do too, and Fine Hotels + Resorts joins them on January 1, 2027.
Lounges. Amex says its Global Lounge Collection covers more than 1,550 lounges, including Centurion. Chase offers its own Sapphire Lounges plus more than 1,300 Priority Pass lounges, with up to two guests. Which one is better depends on your airports — I built Loungeaway to answer exactly that, lounge by lounge.
You Now Have to Track Two Things
Ten years ago you tracked points. Now you track points and a calendar of credits, each on its own reset date, some needing enrollment, some ending in 2027. Spreadsheets work until the first month you forget.
Pick the Coupon Book You’ll Actually Use
Neither card is a scam, and neither is the points machine it used to be. The Reserve is easier to justify if you travel a lot and want credits that work without effort. The Platinum is better if Uber, Resy, lululemon and fine hotels are already part of your life. Either way, the fee only pays off if you capture the credits — and that now takes tracking.